top of page

The Loyal Address: Monarchy, Deference and Episcopacy

20 hours ago
4 min read

Introducing This Guest Blog:


Fr Robert Thompson
Fr Robert Thompson

Funny how quickly the Church remembers its duty of care when a bishop’s had a difficult afternoon.


In The Loyal Address: Monarchy, Deference and Episcopacy, Fr Robert Thompson starts with a speech thanking the King and ends up asking a question the Church of England would rather leave hanging.


When someone challenges a bishop, who gets a call to see if they’re all right?



 I went to General Synod with five minutes on the Loyal Address. I got three. It’s an odd debate to speak in because everybody knows how it’s going to end. The King has been to open Synod. Of course we’re going to thank him. I’m a convinced republican and even I’m going to vote for it. But I’d like us to notice how it feels to stand up in a room where everybody already knows what the loyal answer is.


I’m a subject of His Majesty the King and a citizen of Ireland. I have both passports. I take my oath to the King seriously, and I took him seriously when he asked us to serve all the people of this country. That word all takes me home to Kilburn, to the children who sing in our community choir. If one of them asked me, “Robert, could I grow up to be head of state?”, what could I say? I could tell them, as I do, that they bear the image of God. I’d also have to tell them they’d been born into the wrong family for the job.


Which brings me to Andrew Mountbatten-Windsor, the artist formerly known as Prince. In February, when Andrew’s association with Jeffrey Epstein was again in the news, an interviewer asked his brother Edward how he was coping. Edward said it was “really important to remember the victims”. He was right. What caught my ear was the question. Here was a story about the sexual abuse of girls and young women, and the person somebody thought to ask “How are you?” was a prince. I can imagine doing exactly the same.


Suppose a concern is raised about a bishop I know. I can ring that evening. I’ve got the number. We’ve had dinner together. I know enough about the family to ask after them by name. What about the person who raised the concern? Do I know whether anybody has rung them? You can get quite a long way towards looking after the most powerful person in the story simply by working through the contacts already in your phone.


There is money in this history, too. Before he became James II, the Duke of York governed the Royal African Company. Enslaved Africans were branded D.Y. A royal title burnt into the flesh of someone who bears the image of God. I serve a parish where many people are descended from those who were enslaved. When I stand up to thank the King, I carry that history into the room. The royal family’s place in the ceremony is assured. Somebody from Kilburn gets three minutes to say why the other families belong in the story.


And yes, this has something to do with working-class vocations. Imagine a woman whose neighbours have trusted her for years. They know who turns up when somebody dies. They could tell you why they think she’d make a priest. Will a selection panel hear that authority in her voice? Or will the young man who has talked to people like the panel across a dinner table since he was six strike them as the more natural priest? I’d want to hear from her neighbours before anybody suggested she should work on her confidence.


I kneel before a bishop. I promise obedience in all things lawful and honest. I mean it. Sometimes, though, I wonder what authority a bishop actually has to require what is being asked. And there’s precious little honesty in asking for my view once the decision has been taken.


Now suppose you’ve seen me kneel and heard me make that promise. You need to tell me something about the bishop. Whose side do you think I’m on?


In the Hebrew Scriptures, David takes Bathsheba and arranges the death of her husband, Uriah. Nathan stands before the anointed king and says, “You are the man.” I’ve heard plenty of sermons about Nathan’s courage. What provision have we made for somebody with rather less courage than Nathan who nevertheless has something true to say about a bishop?


After the Makin Review into the Church’s handling of John Smyth’s abuse, an archbishop resigned. By then survivors had waited years for people with authority to act. That is why I’ve asked Synod to give victims and survivors five voting places and to put safeguarding and complaints records under independent control. People who have lived with the consequences of the Church’s decisions should have a vote when the next decision is taken. And somebody trying to find out what happened to them should be able to challenge a refusal to open the file.


On Good Friday I kneel again. The person before whom the Church asks me to kneel has been stripped, mocked and abused. This is the person in whom we recognise God. I’d like somebody watching me on Good Friday to be able to tell, from what I do the rest of the year, what that kneeling means.


So yes, I can thank the King. And when a child in Kilburn asks, “Could I ever be head of state?”, I want to say yes. And if that child asks, “Who will hear me if it’s the bishop?”, I want to give them a name. Someone independent. Someone with the power to act.


`~ Fr Robert Thompson



Guarding the Flock is independent and gives space to voices and perspectives that need to be heard. If you value this work and want to help the blog continue, including providing a platform for guest writers like Fr Robert, please consider buying a coffee. Every bit of support helps keep these conversations going.








bottom of page